Authenticity in materials definitely plays a role, but craftsmanship often makes an even bigger difference. A well-made sword, even if not entirely historically accurate, can feel balanced, responsive, and visually striking. For example, some collectors choose a Japanese katana precisely because the folding techniques and curvature create a unique handling experience that raw material alone can’t replicate. Edge retention, weight distribution, and even subtle hilt ergonomics are all critical. Essentially, the artistry behind shaping and polishing the blade affects both the tactile and aesthetic experience, and that’s why two swords with the same steel can feel worlds apart in practice.