Edited by Max H Schwartz on 2/28/2026, 7:17 am
Bob Shane and I were good friends for about 15 years.
During this time, I never asked him anything about music or the Trio.
Why?
Because in a round about way, he admitted that the genius behind the Trio was Dave.
Without Dave ... there was no Trio.
Stewart gave the Trio another good 5 years.
But, it was never the same without Dave.
But, if Dave had stayed...it would have been a disaster.
For many reasons.
Whiskey Hill Singers made it plain that Dave was headed in the wrong direction.
I keep coming back to this album.
Hangman is the only song that doesn't belong in it.
Otherwise ... after Hungry i, it may have been the best Guard album.


Responses