Here are their cumulative stats:

Newman

Total Record at CSUN 52-35
Big West Record 27-21

DeGeorge

Total Record at Cal Poly 23-31
Big West Record 11-16

Acker

Total Record at LBSU 15-36
Big West Record 7-20


I’m presuming you’re polling on their potential and not what has transpired since the latter is pretty obvious (Newman, hands down). While Acker has turned the narrative around in his 2nd year, we don’t know whether he can replace star players from year to year and still win. Heck, we haven’t even seen his team beat any of the top Big West teams, unless you consider CSUN as such. I think at this point, Newman has to be the choice. He has built 3 teams from scratch and molded them into at least mid-level Big West teams. He doesn’t seem to have the one elite talented player that he had last year (Marcus Adams) but they are still quite competitive.